Published on November 19, 2026 · The mitza.es team

Redesigning a website is tempting: a new look, more speed, a better experience on mobile. But many companies discover, weeks after launching the redesign, that they have lost visits and enquiries. The cause is almost never the design: it is a poorly planned migration. This guide is the checklist we follow to reduce that risk. No redesign guarantees keeping every ranking, but almost all disasters can be avoided.
Before you start: do you really need to redesign?
Redesigning makes sense when the website no longer does its job: it is slow, it looks bad on mobile, it does not convert, it uses technology that is hard to maintain or it does not reflect what you offer. If the problem is only content or speed, sometimes it is enough to improve those without touching the structure. A prior audit tells you what is failing and what is worth keeping.
Checklist before the redesign
- Complete URL inventory. Make a list of all the pages on the current website (with a crawler or from the CMS). Note which ones receive visits and enquiries, and which ones have links from other websites.
- Search Console and analytics data. Export the queries people use to find you and the pages with the most impressions and clicks. These need the most care. If you do not have analytics yet, take a look at our web analytics service.
- Mark the pages that rank. Wherever possible, those pages keep their address, their title, their main heading and the essentials of their content.
- A full backup of the current website (files and database), in case you need to go back. If you do not have an organised system, see the 3-2-1 rule.
- A baseline for speed and errors so you can compare afterwards.
How to decide which addresses stay
- Same address, same content: the ideal option for the pages that rank.
- The address changes, the content stays: you need to redirect the old one to the new one with a 301 (permanent) redirect.
- The page goes away: redirect it to the closest equivalent page (not always the home page) or, if there is no equivalent, let it return a 404 or 410 error on purpose.
- Duplicate or low-value pages: it is a good time to remove or merge them, always with their redirect.
A very common mistake is redirecting everything to the home page: you lose the meaning of each page and confuse users. Another is changing addresses “because they look nicer” when there is no need.
Checklist during the redesign
- Work in a testing environment (staging) and check everything before publishing. Make sure that environment is not accessible to search engines.
- Keep the texts and titles that rank. You can improve them, but do not replace them with others for no reason.
- Keep the heading structure and the important internal links.
- Metadata: unique titles and descriptions on every page; images with alt text.
- Speed and mobile: this is one of the usual reasons for redesigning; do not make it worse. If you need to measure it, there is the website speed audit.
- 301 redirects prepared and tested in the testing environment, with the complete list of old and new addresses.
- Structured data, forms and payment gateway (if there is a store) checked before launch.
Launch day
- Remove any block left over from the testing environment. It is the costliest mistake: a website published with the
noindextag or arobots.txtthat blocks everything stops appearing in search engines. - Turn on the 301 redirects and check a sample of old addresses.
- Publish the new sitemap and submit it in Search Console.
- Check that forms, website emails, payments and the SSL certificate work.
- Let whoever manages your paid campaigns know, in case the landing pages change.
After launch: what to watch for weeks
- Search Console: coverage errors, pages not indexed, 404 errors and the evolution of impressions and clicks against the baseline.
- Broken links and redirect chains that slipped through.
- Real-user speed and errors.
- Conversions: enquiries, calls and sales. A beautiful redesign that lowers conversions is not a success.
Small fluctuations are normal during the first weeks while search engines reprocess the website. A sustained or sudden drop is the sign that something needs fixing. So that the website does not deteriorate over time, it is worth pairing the redesign with WordPress website maintenance that includes updates and backups.
The mistakes that cost the most
- Changing addresses without redirecting them.
- Leaving the testing environment's search engine block in place when you publish.
- Rewriting all the texts and titles without knowing which ones ranked.
- Redirecting everything to the home page.
- Launching without a backup or a plan to go back.
- Not measuring beforehand, and therefore not knowing whether the redesign has improved or worsened anything.
Frequently asked questions
Do you lose rankings when you redesign a website?
It can happen if addresses are broken or content is lost. A careful migration greatly reduces the risk, but there are no guarantees: search engines re-evaluate the website and there may be fluctuations.
How long does it take a website that has lost rankings after a redesign to recover?
It depends on the cause. If the problem is a missing redirect or an indexing block, fixing it as soon as possible shortens the timeline a lot. If it is content that has disappeared, it has to be restored.
Can I change domain when I redesign?
You can, but it is a more delicate migration that adds risk. Unless there is a strong reason, it is better to keep the domain.
What if my website is an online store?
You also need to take care of product pages, categories, orders and the payment gateway, and test the whole purchase process before publishing.
How we can help at Mitza
We do your website redesign with a prior audit, migration of what ranks, redirects and follow-up afterwards. If your current website is limited by its technology, we consider custom web development. Tell us about your case from the contact page.
Related reading: cheap or custom website: how to choose and how much an SEO audit costs in Madrid.